my first was a Shinx. it stayed on my team until i beat the E4 (obviously it was a luxray by then), and i traded it for a kadabara, which evolved and my lv100 Alakazam is now one of the main pokemon in my line up.
what about you?

seems a silly thread considering most people will have all caught the same selection of pokemon first.

Me? - Bidoof

followed by Stary and Shinx which became my Elite Four 'mons.

Starly - and oddly, it took me ages to even find a bidoof on R201. Kricketot was my second, then shinx, then bidoof.

Starly.

I think I made it all the way to Pastoria before I gave in and caught a Bibarel.

In case you didn't know, I am not a fan of Bibarel.

bidoof its now a lvl 78 bibarel

Well, I bet you 1 000 000$ half the people will say bidoof. And that's my answer. I send cash only.

The first species I got was Shinx. Actually, three Shinx in rapid succession. I used the third one.

The first one I actually intended on using on my permanent team was Misdreavus, I think. Mismagius is one of my favorite Sinnoh Pokemon.

I caught Starly first, then Shinx, then Budew, then some others... it wasn't 'till Pastoria that I caught Baba and that was only 'cause It's a good utility Pokemon (HM Slave )

Piplup durrr lol jk.
Uhh it was either a kricketok (dont remember the spelling), or a geodude.

Bidoof Way too many of those around... *sigh*

Oooh, I gots a Krikatune too! I named him Jiminy

Starly, shortly followed by Kricketot and Shinx.

yeah... i wasn't really thinking when i made thread... it seemed like a good idea at the time..
probably because at the time i was bored as all hell, because it appears as if i'm the only one here who doesn't have school during the day..
college steals my nights though

Bored threads are sometimes the best threads.

This isn't one of those times, but you get what I'm saying.

well i cought onix first, cuz i wanted too

Onix? You must have power levelled your starter!

Bidoof - Starly - Kricketot

And as the TV man would say, they were all caught with the last ball I threw!

Shinx. The only one I wanted to catch then, caught two and got the best nature.

It was Bidoof and i hated it on sight!

Bidoof or Starly - I really can't remember that far back I remember waiting around for the next morning for Kricketot though

It's kinda a silly question, I mean, there's Really only three possibilities.

Sir, have you read this thread lately? It says on the front page, some people caught onixes and krickitots first. You should read the index first.

On one of my Pearl games : Starly
On the other: I beat the E4 and got N dex, and I've never EVER caught a pokemon EVER.

One person, not the most credible, or even interesting post said onix, I missed krickitots, but that post was also not much of a conversation starter.

You should look around everyone, and I don't use that term strictly mind you, had Shinx, bidoof, and starly. If you wanted to know about abnormal ones you should have said so, but the way this thread is constructed it's just a way for people to pop in and say bidoof.

Now, I said "Really" there are only 3 possibilities saying, yes there are other possibilities, but we aren't talking about them specifically, instead you open up and encourage people to repeat the same three again and again, perhaps an occasional liar, joker, or just plan different person will pop in with their different answer, but they are quickly lost in a tide of bidoof, starly, shinx and I don't remembers.

So I'm going to resubmit my statement, that's kinda silly.

Starly. Now its my fly and smart contest poke.