What is the deal with people coming up with these kinds of messed up perspectives of children's cartoons?
There's a creepypasta quite like this about the Rugrats in which the toddlers had all passed one way or another and those on screen are versions of them that were (re)imagined by a mentally disturbed Angelica. Having been addicted to that cartoon in my childhood I could write you at least a full page maybe two on the consistency flaws with the complete story. The person who wrote it clearly was not familiar with the cartoon.
While this was not nearly as sloppily written, it still as well has flaws.
Ash had not yet met Officer Jenny or Nurse Joy when the event that was said to have put him in the coma occurred. It's clearly implied that Pallet does not have them because it was not until he reached Pewter City that he met his second Nurse Joy who had to explain to him that she was not the same one from Viridian City.
Though he is shallow with the opposite sex, it seems to be easily forgotten due to the fact that it too heavily over shadows the rest of his character that Brock is actually an intelligent and mature young man. Having been a gym leader, he is an experienced battler despite it not being his area of interest who countless times teaches Ash. One such instance was the secret of Lt. Surge's Raichu. Tell me, how does a zero experienced trainer conjure up the professional knowledge that he would have had to if Brock was a figment of his mind? This goes for any character Ash meets who had enlightened him with experienced knowledge.
There are episodes in the series that give Ash little to no focus, very few but still. The Johto episodes "Dos and Dont's" and "Go West Young Meowth" are both almost entirely focused on the perspectives of Team Rocket. Most episode feature Team Rocket scenes not shared with Ash and Co usually leading up to those they do.
There are several other instances of alternate points of view.
*'Bulbasaur the Ambassador'
- Most of the episode is focused on Bulbasaur who Ash lent to Professor Oak to make peace between a group of feuding pokemon.
*'For Crying Out Loud'
switches points of view between Ash, Brock and another trainer and Misty who was separated from the group when she went to the rescue of a lost Merril.
*'The Breeding Center Secret'
where we first meet the second Team Rocket duo Cassidy and Butch. The Audience finds out they are with Team Rocket before Ash and Co and even James do.
*Pokemon Heroes: Latios and Latias
- Again information and new characters are revealed to the audience before they are to Ash and Co such as the identity of the mysterious mute little girl and a new, third Team Rocket duo.
Celebi, the Voice of the Forest - The film opens up with Brock introducing the basic idea of Pokemon and Ash's journey. The audience is also given a piece of information Ash and Co. never find out: Highlight to view spoiler.
That Sammy who accidentally time traveled from 40 years in the past with a distressed Celebi is Professor Oak as a child.
The whole thing with Ash's father is very clearly information made up by this writer as we don't learn a thing about the guy other than his taking a lot longer than Ash to make it to Viridian City. There is nothing to indicate that he and Delia split, he could have passed away which several theories of his identity happen to be based on. I also do not support any theory which makes Giovanni the father even in a metaphorical sense as it is here. If Giovanni is a father I'd say he's Gary's father, they have similar faces and Gary/Blue did inherit the Viridian City Gym in Silver/Gold/Crystal.
Then we have the Mewtwo explanation which is more evidence that this writer is simply making some stuff up rather than actually trying to be plausible. Take a look at the opening line of this article:http://science.howstuffworks.com/life/i ... /coma4.htm
If they'd actually researched coma treatment they'd know that there is none that can wake the patient nor do doctors attempt it (unless I misunderstood as it wasn't entirely clear). Once stabilized the treatment becomes simply involved only with keeping it that way as well as the patient fed, clean and comfortable.
What is described here is borderline electroshock therapy which is cruel. This Delia Ketchem could sue that doctor for malpractice.
Really the least these people can do is write these things decently.